Rebirth by Jahnavi Barua (Man Asian Literary Prize Longlist)

Rebirth by Jahnavi Barua (Penguin Books India, 2010, 203 pages).

In Jahnavi Barua’s first novel, a pregnant woman addresses lonely, stream-of-consciousness observations to her unborn child. Kaberi has a lot to think about and time on her hands. Her husband, unaware of the pregnancy, has moved in with another woman, leaving his wife in isolation in their apartment in Bangalore where her material needs are met, but emotional and social life is in limbo. She dwells on the past and tries to make sense of the present. Later in the story, the narrator travels home to Guwahati, a small town in the Assam region of northeastern India. The change of setting adds interest and provides some insight into the narrator’s childhood and relationship with her parents, family and friends.

Although I enjoyed the book, it probably will appeal to a limited international readership. Considerations about the meaning of love in an arranged marriage may not travel far outside the immediate context. The husband comes across as a complete jerk, and the narrator begins to understand that she loves him only because that is expected of her. She is working on a book, a project she keeps secret from her husband, who would probably not approve. From time to time he has beaten her, a minor thread of the story that becomes more significant as the narrator takes stock of her life and comes to decisions about the future.

Shadow Man Asian Logo

Logo designed by Matt Todd of A Novel Approach.

Barua is strong on descriptive detail but less successful in developing plot interest. As Kaberi’s mind wanders from topic to topic, the story diverges into a series of vignettes that read like scenes for short stories. Barua first made her literary reputation with a book of short stories, Next Door, and I liked the book well enough to be interested in reading her stories but not well enough to give the novel a wholehearted recommendation. The gentle narrative voice of an ordinary woman examining and questioning the state of her life appealed to me. Her ambiguous situation and reflections on the past held my attention, but I suspect other readers could find the narrative flat. The description of everyday life is fine but understated, and perhaps too matter-of-fact to interest a wide audience.

The book’s social significance as a meditation on women’s lives in India today lifts it to a level of cultural importance. I’m just not convinced the story and characters are sufficiently developed to give the novel a broad appeal.

Rebirth has been longlisted for the Man Asian Literary Prize, and it is up against some strong competition. Having read over half of the longlist now, I feel fairly confident in saying that this novel is not a candidate for the shortlist to be announced on January 10th. It has not been published in the United States; I ordered my copy from a book vendor in India.

Advertisement

11 thoughts on “Rebirth by Jahnavi Barua (Man Asian Literary Prize Longlist)

  1. Fantastic, Fay, I haven’t read your review because I’m hoping to get my copy of Rebirth to read first, but phew! it’s good to have a review of this hard-to-get book for the team!

  2. Lisa, between the six of us we have covered all twelve books on the Man Asian longlist, a great feeling. I’ve finished another one and just need to get the post written.

  3. Courtesy of Penguin India, the fact that this has been so hard to get a hold of has made it like a rare Pokemon – it’s so hard to find, it must be good. Right?

    I’m sad to see that this is not necessarily the case…

  4. Well done Fay … and team. You’ve all done a wonderful job at covering the longlist and with two weeks to go! I’m, still keen to read this book but I guess I won’t if it’s not shortlisted.

    • Sue, the review was meant to be mildly favorable. Hope that comes across. I have been saving a couple of the more celebrated books–positively reviewed–until the very end in order to stay motivated right up until January 10.

      • Yes, it comes across that way … I must say I have no idea which books have been positively reviewed as I tend not to read reviews of books I’m going to read so I look forward to whatever reviews of yours are still coming!

  5. Pingback: Man asian Literary prize 2012 shortlist « Winstonsdad's Blog

  6. Pingback: Rebirth #3 by Jahnavi Barua (Shadow Man Asian Literary Prize 2011) « ANZ LitLovers LitBlog

  7. Back to comment now that I’ve read the book. I enjoyed your review. I’m not sure that the fact that the marriage was arranged limits its interest – the book felt pretty universal to me. I also didn’t really feel that Kaberi’s story felt like short stories. I thought the flashbacks were well integrated. I agree though that it’s the sort of understated book that some readers would find flat or boring. And I suspect some might find Kaberi too passive. But, as you know, I loved it!

  8. Well, Sue, I was wrong about the book’s general appeal. It made the Man Asian Prize shortlist, and other readers are responding more positively than I did, although I did like the book. My comments appear lukewarm compared to the enthusiasm some of the other Shadow Jurors are expressing. It’s great you were able to get your hands on a copy.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s